There must be accountability for torture

The U.S. Senate voted 54–45 on Thursday, 17 May 2018 to approve the nomination of Gina Haspel as the new CIA Director.

After the 9/11 attacks, Gina Haspel worked as Chief of Staff in the CIA’s Counterterrorism Section, the unit responsible for the coordination of the CIA’s infamous rendition, detention and “enhanced interrogation” program.  In late 2002 she was sent to run a “black site” in Thailand where she oversaw interrogations which included torture and with respect to which she subsequently ordered the destruction of videotape evidence.

On the global implications of Haspel being confirmed by the full Senate, Osgoode Hall law professor Craig Scott writes:

Each time the United States’ political and legal systems refuse to pursue any form of accountability for key participants in the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) and Pentagon torture programs, it puts another nail in the coffin of the global struggle against impunity for torture.

But Thursday’s vote is more than a failure to hold a torturer to account. It is a grotesque action to make that torturer the public face of the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency.

Each time U.S. impunity is confirmed, the torture apparatuses of other states are emboldened. They know it makes U.S. criticism of them that much less likely and they also know that their governments can push back with charges of hypocrisy if the U.S. does try to get righteous with them about their own uses of torture. – Craig Scott

During her confirmation hearing, and in written responses Haspel sent to senators after the hearing, she refused to acknowledge the immorality of the CIA’s now defunct torture program, rendering meaningless her assurance to the Committee that she would in future do nothing “immoral” if asked by the President.

Craig Scott also reminds us that torture is not just America’s problem. Referring to the Counterterrorism Unit where Gina Haspel worked, he states:

It was, for example, this program that saw Canadian Maher Arar detained in New York, flown to Jordan, and passed on to suffer horrific torture in Syria.

On the central question of holding torturers to account, Canada fails as well:

…successive Canadian governments — including the present Trudeau government — have refused to call a commission of inquiry to look into the policy and practice of the Canadian military sending detainees in Afghanistan to the substantial risk of torture at the hands of Afghan security agencies widely known to use brutal interrogation methods as standard procedure.

This continued Canadian abdication of “morality and accountability” may one day be rectified by the International Criminal Court.  But why should this be necessary?  Canadians must continue to determinedly and persistently demand made-in-Canada accountability for these immoral and unconscionable acts committed in our name.

For the full blog post by Craig Scott, click: Trump CIA Pick’s Refusal To Condemn All Torture Is Canada’s Moral Problem, Too ( blog, 15 May 2018).

For a detailed and harrowing description of the torture inflicted by the CIA rendition program, click: U.S. Navy Reserve Doctor on Gina Haspel Torture Victim: “One of the Most Severely Traumatized Individuals I Have Ever Seen  (Jeremy Scahill, The Intercept, 17 May 2018).

And see also: The terrible accomplishment of Gina Haspel (Heather Mallick, Toronto Star, 11 May 2018).

Photo credit: Central Intelligence Agency


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

5 Responses to “There must be accountability for torture”

  1. Pete StemkovskyMay 24, 2018 at 8:42 pm #

    Thank you Mr. Craig Scott for the courage to denounce this immorality, this criminality. It seems to me that when an individual, indeed a government, such as this hypocritical Trudeau one, doesn’t denounce torture, they can be considered just as guilty, and just as immoral. Shame on you Mr. Trudeau. You’ve lost my vote AND my respect.

  2. Michael C DunneMay 19, 2018 at 7:00 pm #

    Yanks have never really been civilised. The still live by the law of the gun and see justice as revenge. In such a place torture becomes accepted.

    Still – this is to be expected when more than 50 % of their second nation “citizens” are legally second class |persons| based on their fetal superstions.

  3. Anne StreeterMay 19, 2018 at 6:33 pm #

    Kudos to Craig Scott for keeping this issue front and centre! Shame on the Conservatives and the Liberals for doing everything in their power to obstruct the investigation into Canada’s shocking treatment of detainees in Afghanistan. Mr. Trudeau has been in the business of apologizing. Surely torture would qualify for an apology! As for Gina Haspel, I watched the nomination hearings. She struck me as being pure evil.

  4. Angus CunninghaMay 18, 2018 at 5:19 pm #

    Isn’t there a case to be made that conducting torturer, for from surfacing truth, actually exposes the torturing agency to uncertainties that other, more skillful interrogation techniques have a chance of avoiding?

  5. DennisMay 18, 2018 at 5:19 pm #

    When torture is allowed where is anyone safe. Who are these people? Are they ever justified. Who started this war really?